I am really looking forward to Peeta and him fighting in the bloodbath.
Okay I rewatched the film and his face does not appear in the sky on day two.LightStone123 (talk) 00:39, November 28, 2013 (
Peeta kills District 10 Male[]
I watched and watched the movie and the face of the district killed by Peeta is seem to be that of District 10 Male and not Distrcit 9 Male...
However, the faces of fallen remain four seconds in the sky. The District Male are seen before District Female. In the order :
- from the top the District 5 Male, time of apparence 0 to 4s
- District 8 Male (not seen), time of apparence 8's to 12s
- District 8 Female (not seen), time of apparence 12's' to 16s
- at 16s to 20s the District 9 Male, time of apparence 16's' to 20s
- at 20s to 23s the District 9 Female, time of apparence 20's' to 24s
- at 27s to 28s the District 10 Female, time of apparence 24s to 28s
- at the end District 11 Female, time of apparence 28's to 32s
It thus doesn't have time there to display the face of the District 10 Male… However it is not visible at the time of the second day…
As a result I think that there is an error of timing at the time of the first day and that the District 10 Male died drowned well by Peeta.
What's your point of view? Rhumano (talk) 09:27, January 26, 2014 (UTC)
Though, the D10 male could've just been stunt acting for the D9 male. ~ FenriDarkWolf ~ (talk) 19:10, January 27, 2014 (UTC)
D10 male is stunt acting for Finnick but not for D9 male... sooo Rhumano (talk) 18:58, January 31, 2014 (UTC)
You´re asking for our point of view, Rhumano. I agree with the guy who said that D10M could have been stunt-acting for D9M. There´s evidence for this (altough not confirmed yet):
1. Only 8 cannons on Day 1.
2. D9F´s portrait appears, then there is a moment where Katniss looks at the sky and then D10F´s portrait is seen, but it isn´t appearing and quickly dissapears.
3. Katniss saying that 8 tributes died, not 9.
But it´s just my opinion and I can be wrong. But where can you proof that "D10M is stunt acting for Finnick but not for D9M"? It doesn´t make sense.
JJ97218
Extra Death[]
Maybe the District 10 male was just an extra death and wasn't replacing the District 9 male.
Travis Lane (talk) 19:44, June 28, 2014 (UTC)
There isn't the need to use an extra death. Then, his role was very important, since he almost drowned Peeta, so it is pretty impossible his is an extra death.
GianG (talk) 19:49, June 29, 2014 (UTC)
But how do we know we know he was replacing the District 9 male ?
Travis Lane (talk) 19:59, June 29, 2014 (UTC)
We don't know this, but this is absolutely the best supposition (I have 3 suppositions). His death can't be extra, since he had a main role.
GianG (talk) 20:03, June 29, 2014 (UTC)
I agree with you, GianG. District 10 male´s death cannot be extra. If he actually didn´t die in the bloodbath, the best possibility is that he replaced the male of District 9, because extra deaths don´t make sense and replacing another character DOES make sense. According to you there are 3 possibilities: 1) District 10 male replaced District 9 male and 8 tributes died, 2) He was killed by Peeta and 9 tributes died, 3) One of the District 8 tributes didn´t die and District 10 male was killed. This three speculations you made make sense, but in my opinion, the first is the best. District 10 male´s death cannot be extra, you´re right.
JJ97218
Death theory[]
Nobody is 100% sure about D10 male´s REAL death in the film.
He is seen being drowned by Peeta in Day 1, but it´s possible that he was portraying D9 male.
Then, if his death was on Day 2 in the film too, I made a theory about his death:
He fought Chaff in the jungle in the 6-7 sector. Then, the mutt arrived and attacked. The two tributes tried to flee, but District 10 male was reached and killed. Chaff escaped the sector and later got killed by Brutus. Remember guys, JUST A THEORY.
JJ97218
RE: Death theory
Good theory
GianG (talk) 15:53, July 8, 2014 (UTC)
Die by drowning?[]
We all know that the actor of the tribute who tried to drown Peeta is Jackson Spidell, D10M´s actor, but it´s possible that he was replacing Daniel Bernhardt, D9M´s actor, but we can´t know if Spidell is replacing D9M or he was portraying his own tribute. But something is clear: It seemed just too quick to die by drowning, don´t you think?. It was only like 5 seconds. As Peeta is pulled underwater by the tribute, he crazily moves his arms, and I think I noticed him moving them toward his arms towards his rival´s neck. So, I think Peeta actually snapped D9/10M´s neck, killing him. What do you think?
JJ97218
I think it's unlikely, because Daniel Bernhardnt is a stunt actor himself. Why would they hire him if they needed to replace him ? They could have simply killed off the District 10 man in the bloodbath, and made an error of not showing his face in the fallen.
--Travis Lane (talk) 17:04, October 19, 2014 (UTC)
It´s your opinion, but we can´t know it. Also thet´s not the main topic of my comment.
JJ97218
Actually, that was part of your topic that you posted here on this talk page, and I never said that it wasn't opinion, further more, I am actually pointing out a valid fact. It doesn't really matter how he dies (if you think that's important, I don't really care, tbh) the fact is that he is shown to die in the bloodbath is the confusion. You are putting out another tribute from the victors, who has no contrary or possible relation towards that character. That makes it invalid. Even if that's your opinion.
--Travis Lane (talk) 17:10, October 25, 2014 (UTC)